This morning however, I decided it was time for the detergent backflush clean and on my first try the pressure gauge oscillated wildly around 1-2 bar and never got higher than that. Same thing when I kept playing. There's no water coming out of the portafilter and I don't notice any leaks.

Suggestions?
My guesses are:
- Pump gone bad?
- OPV somehow opening far too early and in an unstable manner?
EDIT: The sound also never reaches the more "subdued" noise that's typical once the pressure is there.
Cheers,
Joe